Democratic vice presidential candidate Sen. Joe Biden, D-Del., left, and Republican vice presidential candidate Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin shake hands after the vice presidential debate at Washington University in St. Louis, Thursday, Oct. 2, 2008. (AP Photo/Tom Gannam)
~ADVERTISING~
Friday, October 3, 2008 8:02 AM CDT
Vice presidential debate: Give us your thoughts on how they did
By JO MANNIES, Courier Lee News Service
ST. LOUIS --- Vice presidential candidates Sarah Palin and Joe Biden spent most of their time
defending or attacking the two men at the top of their tickets — John McCain
and Barack Obama — in a 90-minute debate Thursday night touted as a potential
game-changer.
Whether the Biden-Palin confrontation will live up to its billing as the most
consequential vice presidential debate in history may not be known for days,
when analysts and public opinion polls weigh in.
Immediately after the debate, aides and activists in both camps praised their
candidate's performance. Observers agreed that both avoided the kind of major
gaffe that can send approval ratings plummeting.
Palin, the Republican governor of Alaska, repeatedly emphasized McCain's
promise to keep most of the current federal income tax breaks in place, while
challenging Obama's promise to raise taxes only on people who earn more than
$250,000 a year.
Palin said Obama would end up hiking taxes on far more Americans.
Biden, a veteran U.S. senator from Delaware and a Democrat, defended Obama's
tax proposals while hammering at McCain's plan to tax employer-provided health
insurance and give families an annual $5,000 tax credit to buy their own
coverage.
Biden said McCain's health-insurance plan amounted to a tax increase on many
Americans and would leave millions of them without insurance coverage. Palin
disagreed.
Such back and forth continued when it came to addressing the rising cost of oil
and gasoline, the war in Iraq and foreign policy troubles — particularly the
threats caused by weak or belligerent governments in Iraq, Pakistan and
Afghanistan.
Only one social issue came up during the debate. After some wrangling over
definitions, Palin and Biden both said they opposed same-sex marriage but
supported legal protections for gay couples, such as in the case of hospital
visitations.
Each candidate's approach during the debate reflected their personality. Palin
delivered all of her attacks with a smile and a persistently folksy style.
Biden laced his scholarly responses with a bit of passion, especially when he
mentioned his family.
Palin also had a third task to perform. She needed to bolster her credentials
after facing increasing accusations in recent weeks that she lacked the
knowledge and background in major national and international affairs to serve
as the nation's No. 2. In that quest, she repeatedly touted her record as a
mayor, governor, business owner and mother of five.
Biden avoided any direct attacks at Palin's background, choosing instead to
direct his jabs at McCain and the Bush administration.
The closest Biden came at tweaking Palin came when he called McCain's
health-insurance proposal "the real bridge to nowhere," a reference to a
controversial bridge in Alaska that Palin initially supported but later opposed.
Instead, Biden took exception to Palin's repeated characterization of McCain as
a political maverick. "A maverick he is not," Biden asserted, cited McCain's
agreements with Bush on most major issues.
Palin, meanwhile, repeatedly cited Biden's previous praise for McCain before
Biden became Obama's running mate. She jabbed at Obama's judgment, and accused
him of advocating "a white flag of surrender" with his promise to withdraw most
U.S. troops from Iraq within 16 months.
Palin also faulted Obama for failing to embrace last year's surge of troops in
Iraq, strongly supported by McCain, which generally is deemed to have helped
reduce the level of violence.
At the same time, Palin asserted that a McCain administration would not allow
Iran to acquire nuclear weapons, and she attacked Obama's support for
high-level talks with that nation and others.
Biden countered by citing calls from numerous former secretaries of state,
Republicans and Democrats, for such talks. As for Iraq, Biden said that Obama's
views repeatedly have been embraced by the Bush administration, which has
recently withdrawn some troops, and by the Iraqi government, which also has now
publicly called for a U.S. withdrawal.
As for Iraq, Biden said, "John McCain has been dead wrong when it comes to the
fundamentals of this war."
Afterwards, Obama campaign manager David Plouffe said that Biden "showed a
clear depth in foreign policy," and contended that Palin had given some
incomprehensible answers.
U.S. Sen. Joe Lieberman, I-Conn. and a close McCain ally, praised Palin's
performance and said she "proved tonight that the doubts are unfounded."
The site of Thursday's event took on added significance because Missouri is a
key battleground state, and the latest polls show McCain and Obama to be in a
dead heat.
Thursday's debate marked the fourth time that Washington University has hosted
such a presidential event, though it was the first one to be held at the
university involving the running mates.
Palin left the debate hall immediately for a rally at St. Louis University's
Chaifetz Arena, where she was to be met by thousands of supporters.
The crowd there was enthusiastic during the debate, cheering so loudly at
Palin's closing remarks that they should drowned out half of Biden's closing.
"She did fantastic," said Mary Wilson Stake, 49, of O'Fallon, Ill. "She was
very well-spoken. She had her facts put together well."
Harvey Friedman, an Obama supporter who attended the rally with family who
supports McCain, said he believed the debate was a draw.
"I generally thought both of them did a good job," said Friedman, 69, of
Chesterfield. "Palin definitely did a better job than I thought she would."
Biden didn't join Democrats at any of several local watch parties or rallies.
He flew out of town shortly after the debate to return to his home in Delaware.
Biden wanted to spend time with his son, Delaware Attorney General Beau Biden,
who is leaving today for Iraq as a captain with the Army National Guard.
At a Democratic gathering at the Pageant concert venue in the Loop, more than
250 gathered to cheer Biden.
David Patterson said Biden was in an untenable position.
"When he debated Hillary no one told him not to speak condescendingly," he
said. "He should be able to just debate the issues and let America see what he
stands for. It's an affront that (Palin) has turned this into a freak show."
To hear aides on both sides talk before the debate, Palin planned to be
combative while Biden would appear more conciliatory.
Palin, said spokeswoman Tracey Schmitt, was "going to lay out in no uncertain
terms what is her record of executive leadership and Joe Biden's 35 years in
the confines of Washington D.C."
"Governor Palin has more executive experience than Barack Obama or Joe Biden
combined," Schmitt said.
Meanwhile, Obama senior strategist David Axelrod said in an interview before
the debate that Biden would be emphasizing what sort of change Obama's election
would bring, and contrast that with McCain's.
"He didn't come here with the mind-set of tussling, or a body slam," Axelrod
said.
Debate viewers, he added, "are not turning in to see a sporting event. They're
turning in to see a discussion of the future of this country."
Palin and Biden both flew into Lambert St. Louis International Airport in the
early afternoon, just over an hour apart.
Palin sported a large bandage on her right hand. An aide said she injured it
slightly when she fell while jogging this week at McCain's ranch, where she was
preparing for the debate.
The moderator, Gwen Ifill, also came in with an injury; she broke her ankle
earlier this week. Washington University athletic director John Schael
recruited two members of the football team, starting quarterback Buck Smith and
defensive lineman Tim Taylor, to help Ifill get on stage and into her chair.
Jake Wagman, Adam Jadhav, Kavita Kumar, Steve Giegerich and Todd Frankel of the
Post-Dispatch staff contributed to this report.
More Stories from News » Breaking News
If you would like to comment on this story, please log in with the form below. If you are not a registered user, please
CLICK HERE to sign up.
Due to the amount of spam and negative comments received, the Courier implement a registered-user system for participation in the comment portion of our site. In doing so, the Courier reserves the right to ban any user(s) at any time without notice if we feel they are not following the terms of agreement.
If you are not a registered user, please
CLICK HERE to sign up.

DISCLAIMER: The Courier provides our story commenting feature in order to solicit feedback, debate and discussion on topics of local interest. Please keep in mind that civility is a necessary component of productive conversation. All blatantly inflammatory or otherwise inappropriate comments (i.e. vulgarity, marketing, etc.) are subject to rejection and/or removal. Comments will appear if and when they are approved. For a more in-depth explanation of our policy, please see our
Rules of the Road. Thanks for reading, and thanks for participating.
hetfield wrote on Oct 3, 2008 6:59 AM:
also, i heard palin shake off any concerns about her being inexperienced. she showed more than barack hussein obama did in his debate. she was very articulate and showed that she is more than the dimwit the mainstream media ha portrayed.
I would have asked biden how he thinks he is ready for the presidency when he was thrown out of iowa in the caucus. i would have also repeated many times how he said barack hussein obama is not ready for the presidency. "