Congressman Braley: Criticisms of Cash for Clunkers “absurd”
JOHNSTON – Congressman Bruce Braley called criticisms that the federal Cash for Clunkers program did not significantly affect the fuel-efficiency of vehicles on America’s roads “absurd.”
An analysis of data by the Associated Press found that the most common deals replaced old pickups with new ones that got only marginally better gas mileage. However, fuel-efficient car models such as the Honda Civic and Toyota Camry also were among the top 10 new cars purchased through the program.
Braley said data collected showed that the average increase in mileage for the cars that were traded in and the cars that were bought was 9.2 miles per gallon.
“When you multiply that times the 700,000 vehicles that were placed on the road, it has an enormous impact on fuel-efficiency and on the environment,” Braley told reporters after a taping of Iowa Public Television’s “Iowa Press.”
Braley said most economists who have looked at the program agree that it is one of the most spectacularly successful short-term stimulus programs the federal government has ever passed.
Braley said the program put nearly 40,000 people back to work in manufacturing facilities making automobiles or component parts.
“I think it’s been an overwhelming success, and I’m very proud to have been one of the original sponsors,” Braley said.
When asked whether he would support a second round of Cash for Clunkers, Braley said he didn’t know. He expressed support for a “Cash for Caulkers” proposal that would help people improve the energy efficiency of their homes.
“It’s going to create a lot of economic opportunity for those that are involved in weatherizing and upgrading homes and businesses,” Braley said. “So I think that as we need to focus on creating jobs in this economy that it may be the type of thing that would make sense short term.”
He did not have an estimate of how much the plan would cost.
During the taping of the show, Braley called his recent vote in favor of the health care reform bill “one of the proudest votes I’ve ever taken on the House floor.”
He said it will improve access to health care for thousands of Iowans, increase reimbursement rates for health care providers, and give many seniors security that their drug benefits will improve.
Braley said he didn’t think the vote would make him vulnerable as he seeks re-election in Iowa’s 1st Congressional District.
“If I take a tough vote like the one I did on health care, and it results in me not getting re-elected, I can live with that vote,” Braley said.
About